9.22.2009

Which Languages Are Worth Saving

Language extinction is clearly a burgeoning problem in the world. According to the "Linguists," languages are literally dying off every week. Unfortunately, it seems almost impossible to preserve every single one in existence. Thus, it is necessary to have qualifications for which languages are chosen to save. For it to be rescued, I think a written form must exist. This is because time typically is an antagonist to linguists. Therefore, if a written form has not yet been established, they will have to donate a large amount of effort to creating this. Consequently, they will waste precious time they have in discovering new words, phrases, and other nuances of the language in question. Another condition that should exist is the potential to be modernized. Like Evolution, if a language cannot adapt to the times, it cannot be used in all settings, especially for educational purposes.

On the other hand, a language that would not be worth saving is one that is spoken in a dangerous area. For instance, in "The Linguists," the men risk their lives by going to the Sora village, which harbors insurgents. Although it is noble to put protecting history before one's life, it should not be the norm. For example, had the men been killed, not only would the records they made of the language be lost, but so would they. Thus, there is no resulting benefit. Another condition that would make a language not worth saving would be if there are less than fifty speakers and it is not being passed down to generations. This is because there is an obvious lack of enthusiasm, which is crucial in this process.

Overall, it is hard to tell a group of people that their language is not "worth" saving. However, I truly believe that as long as there is a will, there is a way.

5 comments:

  1. I like how you provided a brief background on the topic of language death in general and emphasized that it is impossible to preserve all languages. Your analogy to evolution is very appropriate since languages go through extinction and natural selection just as organisms do. You also did a good job of presenting this topic as one that is subjective and controversial through your short concluding paragraph.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I completely agree with the fact that a language has to have a written form in order for it to be worth saving. In addition to the extra time linguists would have to devote to forming a written language, the speakers of the language probably wouldn't have as vibrant a culture to save as languages with written forms have. Without the written language, there are no books and documuments that portray the knowledge and thought processes of the culure. I also like how you concluded by saying that it's hard to tell whether or not people should try to save a language. There are just so many factors to consider and everyone views different ones as more important than others.

    ReplyDelete
  3. That's an interesting point you bring up that speakers of a language without a written form probably don't have as vibrant a culture. This is something I had not thought of and I think that it's pretty accurate. This is simply because so much of "culture" is based around literature, plays, music, and other entertainment that needs to be documented. Obviously oral tradition exists, but it's not as influential as having something tangible and committed to paper.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree about having a written form being one of the most important factors in being able to save a language and I like how you related the dying of languages to Darwinism to create a linguistic Darwinist view. I hadn't thought of a culture being more vibrate because of having a written form

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think your argument is strong in the aspect that it is multi-layered, and I would say very well built. I like the way you structured it into multiple paragraphs, because to me it makes it feel more structured and organized. However, there are a few points that I disagree with in your argument. You discuss how making a written form to a language takes up so much time and effort that it isn't worth it, and even if it was by the time you were finished the language might already be dead. I disagree with this point. I do agree that making a written form to a language would take time and resources, but I don't think It is really a huge obstacle to saving a language. In fact I think it would be pretty easy to create a written form to a language, and it would only be a small step in saving an endangered language. I also did not like how you said if there are less than fifty speakers the language is not worth saving. The number of speakers is not as important as how the community of speakers interacts. Perhaps a community of fifty speakers highly value their language but the state forces harsh language restrictions on them resulting in the language not being passed down to the next generation. In this case I would say that a language community of fifty speakers would be worth saving even if the language wasn't being passed on to the next generation.

    ReplyDelete