11.22.2009

John Stewart Commentary

There are a variety of practices that John Stewart criticizes surrounding the media's discourse on politics. In this episode, he focuses on CNN as a source of political news and debates. One aspect he attacks is how the news station seems to ignore the importance of fact-checking. A multitude of congressmen and other "authority figures" make televised speeches involving statistical figures, which are blindly accepted as truth. However, as John Stewart points out, the politicians are oftentimes wrong about the evidence they are using to support their arguments. Not only is the number inaccurate, they rarely commit themselves to citing a specific number. For instance, one man said "between one hundred to two hundred billion." He is incredibly vague, thus, giving himself the chance for his statement to be correct.

Another practice John Stewart criticizes is the role of the moderator in debates. Firstly, the moderator typically cuts people off when they are in the middle of a point in order to allow the other person to have equal time. Therefore, this ultimately makes the whole debate pointless. Often times this happens when the moderator says "Let's leave it there." Typically, this helps the show end within the allotted time slot that has been provided by the television station. However, as Stewart points out, CNN is a twenty-four hour news service. Therefore, there is no reason that they do not have time to completely cover all issues. Consequently, the moderator should not be working towards ending the debate. Instead, he or she should be fostering the debate, so that it continues.

There a few ways that these concerns can be addressed in academic discourse. One way is to require all discourse to be checked at least two times before it is aired. That way, when a politician speaks, he will not be able to persuade the audience with examples that are not accurate. Another way is to have the moderator more educated on the subject. Then, he or she will be more aware of faulty arguments and be able to call attention to this. Furthermore, CNN should allow more time for both sides in a debate to fully flush out their arguments. That way the debate is actually beneficial. Instead now, the audience is forced to watch people be cut off and frustrated on the television screen.

11.21.2009

Extra Credit Blog # 2- Logical Fallacies

In "An Argument Against Marijuana and Self-Destruction," by Jim Spears, the author engages in a "slippery slope" logical fallacy to prove his point. In the Writing 140 Course Book, this is defined as a fallacy that "implies that a small step in a certain direction, in personal choice or social policy, will inevitably lead one down a slippery slope toward ruin and disaster." This is exactly what Spears does in his argument. He basically states that legalizing marijuana will inevitably lead to poor people being uninsured. He indicates that one policy will lead to the loss of health care for many. Furthermore, it is a hasty generalization, "a broad claim made on the basis of narrow evidence," because there are no facts supporting his statements. Instead, he tries to validate each sentence with "I assume." Finally, it is also an example of oversimplification, "an argument in which complex causal relationships are reduced or ignored in favor of a simple claim that fails to address significant dimensions of the issue." This is because he disregards other factors that could lead to poor people losing their insurance plans. Some which may have to do more with the economy right now, than with the legalization of marijuana. For instance, he says:

"I think there is a problem with the assumption that smoking marijuana harms no one other than the smoker... I am inclined to believe that the marijuana smoker is as likely or more likely to get emphysema from smoking marijuana as he would from smoking cigarettes. I also am inclined to assume that if enough people smoke marijuana and suffer from emphysema that there will be a tremendous burden on the shoulders of health-care providers, which translates into an increased cost to people who are insured and who need insurance.

The harm that one incurs from smoking marijuana is transferred to those that do not. A similar case can be made for smoking cigarettes, for drinking alcohol in excess, and for obesity.

Obviously, the more health-care costs, the more people have to pay for it. However, the more that health-care costs, the more likely it is that poorer people will go uninsured."


http://contactjms.newsvine.com/_news/2009/01/04/2273855-an-argument-against-marijuana-and-self-destruction

If anyone is interested further, below is a comical skit in which someone purposely constructs a "slippery slope" argument against medical marijuana.

Extra Credit Blog # 1- Logical Fallacies

Below is a public service announcement that was released around the 2008 presidential election. The work is filled with a multitude of celebrities, who all work to urge Americans to vote via witty dialogue. Thus, this is a perfect example of the logical fallacy, "false authority." According to the writing 140 course book, "This fallacy bases its appeal on an authority figure who lacks competence in the field under consideration." All of the stars in question are in the entertainment industry. They do not work in politics and there is very little evidence to prove that they, themselves, engage in what they are trying to encourage the viewers to do. Not to mention the fact that some of the stars are actually from other countries. Therefore, they legally cannot participate in this display of democracy. For example, Sascha Baron Cohen and Orlando Bloom are from England, while Ryan Reynolds is from Canada.

Consequently, this type of logic can be extremely effective, but also dangerous. Celebrities nowadays have a great power over the public. Therefore, if they say they do something or buy something or use something, then the public tends to believe what the celebrities say without questioning the accuracy. However, in this situation, the celebrities are actually using the power and prestige that they have for good. Sometimes they can be found doing this for charities as well. Otherwise, they can be found shamelessly plugging hair colors, food, and other products.

Here is the example:

11.16.2009

Sacred Language, Spoken Language (Extra Credit)

On Thursday, November 12, 2009, the movie Sacred Language, Spoken Language was screened. It is a documentary, directed by Nurith Aviv, a French-Israeli filmmaker, and is focused primarily on Hebrew as a language. In the film, the main discussion is centered around the difference between Hebrew as a “sacred language,” the religious vernacular of the Torah, and Hebrew as a “spoken language,” the modern variety. Cinematically, the film is structured to present a series of Jewish speakers, all of Israeli nationality, who provide personal anecdotes about the tension and overall confusion they have felt when attempting to decide which language is more appropriate to use. On a whole, most people had conflicting views about whether or not the “spoken version” was acceptable. For instance, Orly Casel-Bloom, one of the interviewees, seemed almost hesitant to use the “spoken language” whole heartedly. She conveyed that not using the “sacred language” could possibly bar her from entering Heaven. Furthermore, she even joked that she gave all of her kids religious names, so that she could tell God she did not tamper with the way he intended Jewish pronunciation to be.

Thus, when taking the whole work in context, it was a great film to help explore Hebrew linguistically. It worked to dispel the idea that Hebrew is still flourishing without any problems, as most commonly think. For example, ever since the language almost went extinct and then was resurrected, many people continue to believe that it is being passed down from generation to generation in a healthy manner. However, by showing these interviews with people spanning across all of Israel, it is clear that this is not the case. One person in the film even mentioned that the youth today is not bothering to learn “proper” Hebrew themselves. Following this statement, there were verbal affirmations from some of the older speakers in the audience watching the movie, thus indicating the general hesitation people feel when they notice subsequent generations drifting away from using the high variety Hebrew, towards the low variety Hebrew, and even worse, mixing the two.

On the other hand, the film does a good job at showing the practical use of the “spoken language.” Some reference in their interviews how this variety is necessary, simply because it has acquired new words that are of practical use in the modern world. The “sacred language,” on the other hand, has not had that lexical expansion, because it has been preserved. Therefore, the “spoken language” is important to have. Furthermore, it also takes an interesting approach by displaying music and poetry that uses the “spoken language.” This was a very moving and incredible part of the film, because it showed how the “spoken language” could be an art form, and consequently, of high culture. Therefore, instead of preaching her overall message, the filmmaker showed examples of how the “spoken language” can be beautiful as well and then lets the audience decide for themselves whether or not they agree.

Hence, the movie is successful in its thematic aim of presenting the continuing struggle over what is the “right” way to speak, an issue that extends far beyond Hebrew itself. However, the main critique is that because the documentary is entirely in Hebrew, it is hard to follow at times. For instance, because of the monotonous droning of the speakers and the continuous sound and image of the landscape as the train moves from location to location, it is very easy to lose what is being discussed. Thus, although it was necessary for the film to be in Hebrew, there were other cinematic techniques that could have been used to make the work more engaging and therefore, easier to follow. Some of these include not setting the speakers against white backgrounds, using more interesting angles, or engaging the speakers in a more energetic way. However, the filmmaker is an award-winning one for a reason.

11.09.2009

Pawk tha Cah (Park the Car)

In regards to the advantages of keeping access to non-standard dialects, there are many. One is that the unique way of speaking helps listeners pin point the general area where the speaker is from and also leads to immediate identification. Thus, without the speaker having to elaborate, the listener can already begin to discern facts about the speaker. Therefore, it could help communication, because then the listener knows what may or may not be appropriate topics to address or ways to behave. Conversely, this could also lead to stereotypes. It is hard when someone so blatantly displays that he or she is from a specific area to not make assumptions. However, the use of dialects prompts this type of thinking. Not to mention, the entertainment industry on a whole plays into these preconceived notions, advancing dialects to be a part of characterization, more so than a manner of expressing oneself as a result of the surrounding environment.

However, although there is a duality in the function of dialects and the way they are perceived, it is possible to keep access open. This is mostly because there are greater priorities to focus on right now in the world. Thus, trying to root out dialects would simply be gratuitous. Instead, the focus should be on making sure that people understand how to speak Standard American English in addition to their home variety. Overall, this should not be a huge task, because people from all over the United States, for instance, have been successful one way or another. Furthermore, it is important to keep in mind that many people already go through rigorous training in order to learn how to speak right for their profession. Some of these include actresses, singers, lawyers, journalists, and other public figures. Thus, citizens who represent America do normally speak "properly."

11.03.2009

My Fair Lady on Review

My Fair Lady is a movie that focuses around a young female, Eliza Doolittle, who is introduced to the audience as a poor flower girl. She speaks with a Cockney dialect, one that originally formed so thieves could communicate without others understanding them. Therefore, it is typically associated with a lower level of society. When Henry Higgins, a phoneticist, meets her, he wages a bet with another man that by simply fixing the way she speaks and expresses herself in the way he deems to be "right," he could pass her off as a duchess. Through this process as Eliza refines her manner of speaking, it is clear that she becomes distanced from her former rank in society. This is most evident when no one recognizes her after she returns to her old neighborhood. On the other hand, she still does not completely fit in with the aristocracy, who have been of this rank since birth.

This movie is a perfect example of the disparity between correlation and causation. For instance, received pronunciation, also known as the "Queen's English," is typically associated with people who work among high society. Normally, the people who speak this way are rich. However, although this is true, it is not because of this that these people are nobility. Rather, they simply are characterized by the dialect. Similarly, this is the same in the movie. For instance, although removing the Cockney accent makes Eliza sound refined, the actual way she speaks does not make her a duchess. There are many other factors to be considered.

This is an example of the way Eliza sounded initially:


Then, this is her uncovering how to speak "properly":

Our Green Future: America's Young Environmental Leaders Speak Out

On Tuesday, October 27th, the second event in the speaker series for social issues occurred. There were three guests who were all Brower Youth Awardees with very impressive resumes. One was Rachel Barge, the director and founder of Campus Inpower, the second was Billy Parish, the founder of the Energy Action Coalition, and the third was Erica Fernandez, a student who has helped save her community from more toxic air pollution. There were many aspects of these presentations that made it more successful than the first talk, given by Simran Sethi. Firstly, this group was actually inspiring. They lead by example, showing that hard work can actually propel initiatives to become large, well-supported programs that make a difference in the world. All encouraged the audience that they had the power to do the same. Secondly, they were very organized in the points that they wanted to make. For instance, Billy Parish had a power point to accompany his speech, which broke down the facts he wanted to hit and thus, made a stronger impression on the audience. Thirdly, they all stressed the incredible importance of halting global warming and used facts and examples to substantiate their claims.

However, there were some negative aspects of their speeches. Firstly, like Sethi, they did not offer many solutions for how to stop global warming. Instead, they focused on explaining their efforts to stop global warming, rather than how the audience could join in the fight. This is a problem, because if the audience leaves inspired, but does not know what to do, then nothing will most likely come of it. Secondly, there were certain tactics that proved to be ineffective. For instance, the third speaker focused on race relations. Although, this is clearly a problem in terms of the environment and polluted areas, this should not have been the center of the speech. That is because it presents the audience with too many problems at once, and it is a proven fact that people who feel overwhelmed by issues in the world that need fixing, will typically not do anything. However, if people can channel all their energy to attack one problem, then tasks are accomplished. Therefore, it is for this reason that the speakers left a lasting impression, but had some logistics that needed to be fix.


If anyone is interested in learning more about the Brower Youth Awards or what we can do to help save the environment, check out the below link:

http://www.broweryouthawards.org/