In "An Argument Against Marijuana and Self-Destruction," by Jim Spears, the author engages in a "slippery slope" logical fallacy to prove his point. In the Writing 140 Course Book, this is defined as a fallacy that "implies that a small step in a certain direction, in personal choice or social policy, will inevitably lead one down a slippery slope toward ruin and disaster." This is exactly what Spears does in his argument. He basically states that legalizing marijuana will inevitably lead to poor people being uninsured. He indicates that one policy will lead to the loss of health care for many. Furthermore, it is a hasty generalization, "a broad claim made on the basis of narrow evidence," because there are no facts supporting his statements. Instead, he tries to validate each sentence with "I assume." Finally, it is also an example of oversimplification, "an argument in which complex causal relationships are reduced or ignored in favor of a simple claim that fails to address significant dimensions of the issue." This is because he disregards other factors that could lead to poor people losing their insurance plans. Some which may have to do more with the economy right now, than with the legalization of marijuana. For instance, he says:
"I think there is a problem with the assumption that smoking marijuana harms no one other than the smoker... I am inclined to believe that the marijuana smoker is as likely or more likely to get emphysema from smoking marijuana as he would from smoking cigarettes. I also am inclined to assume that if enough people smoke marijuana and suffer from emphysema that there will be a tremendous burden on the shoulders of health-care providers, which translates into an increased cost to people who are insured and who need insurance.
The harm that one incurs from smoking marijuana is transferred to those that do not. A similar case can be made for smoking cigarettes, for drinking alcohol in excess, and for obesity.
Obviously, the more health-care costs, the more people have to pay for it. However, the more that health-care costs, the more likely it is that poorer people will go uninsured."
http://contactjms.newsvine.com/_news/2009/01/04/2273855-an-argument-against-marijuana-and-self-destruction
If anyone is interested further, below is a comical skit in which someone purposely constructs a "slippery slope" argument against medical marijuana.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Good job finding an example that illustrates 3 logical fallacies. The most prominent fallacy that this example demonstrates is slippery slope; his argument that legalizing marijuana will lead to poor citizens being uninsured has some merit but the way that he presents it is faulty. He bases everything on his own opinion when instead, he should be quoting research statistics and facts from credible sources to bolster his argument.
ReplyDeleteWow that article was full of logical fallacies! Not only was the slippery slope prominent, but the hasty generalization was pretty blatant too. Like you said, he kept using phrases like "I assume," "I imagine," and "I am inclined to believe," which all show that nothing he says is based on fact and that it is all his own opinions. In addition, the video was a great example of an exaggerated slippery slope.
ReplyDelete