11.09.2009

Pawk tha Cah (Park the Car)

In regards to the advantages of keeping access to non-standard dialects, there are many. One is that the unique way of speaking helps listeners pin point the general area where the speaker is from and also leads to immediate identification. Thus, without the speaker having to elaborate, the listener can already begin to discern facts about the speaker. Therefore, it could help communication, because then the listener knows what may or may not be appropriate topics to address or ways to behave. Conversely, this could also lead to stereotypes. It is hard when someone so blatantly displays that he or she is from a specific area to not make assumptions. However, the use of dialects prompts this type of thinking. Not to mention, the entertainment industry on a whole plays into these preconceived notions, advancing dialects to be a part of characterization, more so than a manner of expressing oneself as a result of the surrounding environment.

However, although there is a duality in the function of dialects and the way they are perceived, it is possible to keep access open. This is mostly because there are greater priorities to focus on right now in the world. Thus, trying to root out dialects would simply be gratuitous. Instead, the focus should be on making sure that people understand how to speak Standard American English in addition to their home variety. Overall, this should not be a huge task, because people from all over the United States, for instance, have been successful one way or another. Furthermore, it is important to keep in mind that many people already go through rigorous training in order to learn how to speak right for their profession. Some of these include actresses, singers, lawyers, journalists, and other public figures. Thus, citizens who represent America do normally speak "properly."

3 comments:

  1. Good points at the end of your post about how everyone learns how to speak their own "proper" form of English. No matter what type of accent or dialect you have, as long as you learn it well then that's all that should matter. Despite this, like you said, there are stereotypes that go along with almost all types of dialects. Because of this, people are often misjudged and are given unequal opportunites in certain endeavors. So if there is a way to make speakers learn SAE for use in public while maintaining their own dialect for use at home or in their special profession, then that seems like it would certainly solve the problem.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like how you brought up the point that dialects provide some information about a person and open up topics for discussion in communication. Also, I agree that the entertainment industry solidifies the already prominent stereotypical beliefs that people hold against speakers with strong dialects. Despite this problem, switching from a non-standard to a standard dialect is not as difficult as switching from a H variety to a L variety. Since the basic grammar and vocabulary is to a large extent the same, speakers of non-standard varieties mostly just have to learn to speak with the correct accent. Therefore, it is to the advantage of non-standard dialect speakers to learn the standard dialect.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree that by maintaining one's dialect you are able to gather information about that person so you know how to talk to them and what should be discussed. I also like how you brought up that fact that everyone learns their own "correct" form of e speech. It interesting to know that it is harder for an individual to learn how to speak "incorrect" than it is to speak "correctly".

    ReplyDelete