My Fair Lady is a movie that focuses around a young female, Eliza Doolittle, who is introduced to the audience as a poor flower girl. She speaks with a Cockney dialect, one that originally formed so thieves could communicate without others understanding them. Therefore, it is typically associated with a lower level of society. When Henry Higgins, a phoneticist, meets her, he wages a bet with another man that by simply fixing the way she speaks and expresses herself in the way he deems to be "right," he could pass her off as a duchess. Through this process as Eliza refines her manner of speaking, it is clear that she becomes distanced from her former rank in society. This is most evident when no one recognizes her after she returns to her old neighborhood. On the other hand, she still does not completely fit in with the aristocracy, who have been of this rank since birth.
This movie is a perfect example of the disparity between correlation and causation. For instance, received pronunciation, also known as the "Queen's English," is typically associated with people who work among high society. Normally, the people who speak this way are rich. However, although this is true, it is not because of this that these people are nobility. Rather, they simply are characterized by the dialect. Similarly, this is the same in the movie. For instance, although removing the Cockney accent makes Eliza sound refined, the actual way she speaks does not make her a duchess. There are many other factors to be considered.
This is an example of the way Eliza sounded initially:
Then, this is her uncovering how to speak "properly":
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I like how you summarized the idea of how it takes more than learning a dialect to establish one's place in society. Just because Eliza learned the better variety doesn't mean she can live like an aristocrat for the rest of her life. She didn't grow up in that society and by only switching over to the aristocrats' language, she will not be able to fit in well with that lifestyle. In addition, like you said, she can't really go back to her flower girl society since she would be perceived as being better than the rest of her friends and co-workers. Basically, by spending time with Mr. Higgins learning the dialect, she put herself in a very difficult position when faced with the problem of where she belongs in society.
ReplyDeleteI think your blog entry answers the essay prompt that asks "To what extent are we defined by language/dialect?" As you stated, the Cockney dialect was originally the language of thieves and is associated with lower classes. Therefore, Eliza was seen as inferior by Higgins. On the other hand, by speaking proper standard English (Queen's English), Eliza was able to fit into higher society and command respect from others.
ReplyDeleteI think that you're trying to say that you can take the girl out of the lower class society but you really cant take the personality that she has gained from living in that society out of the girl. I agree with you that just by changing language does not mean you will turn into a duchess
ReplyDeleteI think Anthony pretty much just summed up my argument in his first sentence. That is a great way to put it.
ReplyDelete