On Tuesday, September 29th, Simran Sethi came to speak to an auditorium of college students. She spoke of the power to change existing within each of us, however, fell short of being inspiring. She thought that by leaving out facts and important information, she would somehow find a way to make this global issue more personal for us. Unfortunately, it had the opposite effect. As someone who has very general knowledge of the subject at hand, I felt isolated because I did not know much about the subject, which she took for granted that I did. What I think she may have overlooked is that tangible information resonates with students. For instance, we spend a lot of time reviewing documents and lectures that are filled with facts. Then we filter this and hold with us the ones that resonate. For instance, Professor Simpson telling us that there are languages dying every week makes me want to fix this problem, more so than him finding ways to point out how I connect with my own language. Therefore, the same logic can be applied to this worldwide crisis.
I also left the lecture feeling frustrated. For over an hour, she pointed out all the problems that were wrong with the environment. Yet, she never offered a solution to them. She mentioned using special light bulbs, but did so in a way that seemed like she was almost dismissing it. I understand that she was attempting to connect to us on a deeper level. However, she fell short of accomplishing this, by making her presentation disjointed, confusing, and lacking a clear point. Often times, she would mention an idea, which would seem like it could be the main one. Although, she never would reference back to it, thus, rendering it irrelevant. Therefore, overall, the discussion was uninformative.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I really liked how you compared her speech to one of Professor Simpson's lectures. I bet if she gave more concrete information about the problem at hand, like you said, we would have left the auditorium feeling more inspired to do something about the environment. For a topic like this, it would have been much better if she stopped trying to make the matter personal and instead just gave us facts and statistics. In addition, I agree that much of her speech was irrelevant; I could never seem to pick out a central idea or theme that she was trying to deliver.
ReplyDeleteSimilar to you, I also lack general knowledge about the environment, so I agree with you and Cameron that Sethi would have been able to accomplish more had she provided us with some facts and statistics. These would have been very helpful for us because information on environmental pollution and its effects are drastic enough to leave an impression on apathetic students. From there, she would have been able to more successfully encourage us to take initiative to save the environment because we would actually be educated by the facts and take an interest in seeking to improve the conditions of our surroundings.
ReplyDelete