9.01.2009
"A German Lesson" Reviewed
During the article, "A German Lesson: the Fallacy of One True Path," by Daniel Jonah Goldhagen, the author makes an analogy between the Pope's beliefs and Nazi Germany's beliefs. He does this to suggest a similarity between the two. Like the Nazi's, the Pope feels that people of his kind are superior to any other. For example, the Pope believes in "relativism." Thus, he thinks the only way to get to Heaven is by being a Catholic. On the other hand, the Pope does not try to enslave and kill everyone else in his quest to form a super-race. Yet, Goldhagen suggests, simply through critical reasoning, that these exclusive theories evolve somewhat from Benedict's experience with the Nazis when he was younger. Furthermore, the author does it in a way that it is not precocious and accusatory. Rather, he uses rhetoric to make the reader come to the intended conclusion for himself or herself.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Hi, Elisha! I'm in your blog group. Here's my comment:
ReplyDeleteI think that your second sentence "He does this to suggest a similarity between the two" is somewhat redundant of the first sentence. Also, you stated that Goldhagen's purpose for comparing the two is to point out that the pope's theories were a result of influence from his experiences with the Nazis but I think that Goldhagen's purpose is more to advise against believing in "one true path," as stated in the title of the article." Overall, good job on stating the parallels between the pope and the Nazis.
I think that Goldhagen was not so much comparing the two as he was trying to compare how they believe in the fallacy of one true path and the close mindedness of both The Pope and Nazi Germany. I do agree with on the fact that expieriences do shape ones thoughts and how they will continue to think
ReplyDeleteI like how you first compared the "superiority" factor between the pope and the Nazis but then explained how the pope's views are much less extreme than those of the Nazis. I agree that even though their mindsets were similar, their intentions were very different. The only thing I disagreed with, however, was that I thought the author's tone was a little accusatory. It seemed as though Goldhagen was putting down the pope in every paragraph due to his similarities to the Nazis.
ReplyDeleteBlee - I do agree that the second statement is somewhat redundant. However, I wanted to emphasize that fact, just because it is central to the argument of the author and my analysis. Although overall, I understand the point you were trying to make.
ReplyDeleteBlee and Anthony - I also concur with both of you that Goldhagen's point was to advise against "one true path." Yet, I feel that the way he was able to achieve this was by comparing the Pope and Nazi Germany. Thus, by pointing out the flaws in logic, he achieves his purpose. Ultimately, this is what I was trying to convey.
Ctrodello - I think that whenever someone is compared to Nazi Germany, there is going to be a negative undertone. Therefore, the Pope is obviously presented unfavorably. However, I think the author does a good job in not being too forward with the comparison. He, himself, even explains that the goals of both parties were very different.
Also, I think his point in comparing the Pope to The Nazi's is to simultaneously make us re-evaluate our own critical reasoning skills. For example, the Pope is a man who is generally considered to be holy and good. However, Goldhagen uses this image to show the audience a more negative side to the Pope. As a result, this makes the reader ask oneself what other opinions does one have that have been force fed to one, instead of decided for oneself?
ReplyDeleteElisha, yes I guess no one can really avoid being negative when comparing anything to the Nazis. Goldhagen could have certainly been more accusatory than he was in his article. In addition, I like your second thought about using this article to show the other side of the pope. It is a very good hypothesis and you articulated it very well.
ReplyDeleteI really like the way you presented your argument, and the paragraph seems to flow from one thought to the next. I'm going to have to agree with Blee, that the second line repeats your first though. I do see what you mean about trying to emphasize the fact however, I still find it repetitive. I see how your arguing that the purpose of the article is to steer away from on true path. However, it seems to me that you focus a little to much on how he the author does this rather than the purpose.
ReplyDelete