9.08.2009

Linguistics 115 and Critical Thinking

The Linguistics 115 class helps students develop critical thinking skills in a variety of ways. Firstly, it is required that essays are written in the class. Two of these, for example, forces the students to analyze films that are viewed and then to form a coherent opinion and conclusion about them. This, in turn, forces the students to think for themselves, instead of relying purely on the words of the professor. Furthermore, this incorporates an accommodation of uncertainty, because in terms of rhetoric, there is not a clear right or wrong answer. Secondly, the students have to attend discussion. During this time, students must decide what the intent is of certain articles, why particular facts are relevant, and why this information is important in today's world. In addition, this also incorporates an accommodation of uncertainty, because these thoughts are typically subjective and vary from person to person. Thus, the class as a whole helps foster critical thinking skills, by making students formulate ideas themselves via application of knowledge.

4 comments:

  1. I like how you incorporated the movie commentaries into your explanation of the class dealing with critical thinking. It didn't even cross my mind while writing my post that those essays make you decide for yourselves about the topics and form coherent essays about them. So good job on that. I didn't agree, however, with your explanation of the discussion sections. At least in my discussions section, the TA told us that we didn't even have to attend and that all we would really be doing is listening to her go over the material already taught by Dr. Simpson. She made it sound like we wouldn't be doing any critical thinking in those sections at all!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good job on bringing up the incorporation of films, something diverging from the mainstream responses. I think that the first film he played for us really helped us to take a fresh perspective of code-mixing by listening to the commentaries of students and professors in Hong Kong. I also agree with you on the idea that rhetoric never has one objective answer. (We have to write essays in Social Issues too?...or were you referring to the affiliated Writ 140 class?)

    ReplyDelete
  3. As far as discussions go, I wrote that response before actually attending class. I was sick, so I missed the first meeting. After going this past week, I must agree with you!

    Blee - I was referring the essays that we have to write in Social Issues.

    Thanks for the comments!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I really like how you talked about analyzing the films. That thought never even occurred to me. I would actually agree somewhat with what you wrote about the discussions in your original blog. Even though a lot of the discussion period is simply recovering information presented in the actual class, I think there is still some debate over certain topics. At least I find that students differ and discuss opinions during the discussions.

    ReplyDelete