10.13.2009
Hawaiian Apology
As mentioned in the previous post, an apology was actually made by President Bill Clinton to the Hawaiians on behalf of the United States for overthrowing their government. Therefore, it is successful in that Clinton and Congress both acknowledge the crimes the government committed and seem genuinely sorry in doing so. However, it fails to offer a sound explanation as to why this happened, not to mention reparations. Thus, this makes the apology almost irrelevant, because by simply saying, "Yes, we did that," it does not actively take the first step towards the healing process. This, in turn, has made Native Hawaiians more restless for independence. Hence, in this case, the apology did more harm then good. This is because the American government publicly recognized its faults, but still is not going to make an effort to reverse the negative policies.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Like Kelleher says in her article, the four parts of an apology are acknowledging the offense, explaining why it happened, expressing shame, and offering reparations. All Clinton's apology did was fulfill the first requirement, classifying the apology as ineffective and not genuine. Maybe if he actually explained the cause and gave suggestions as to how to repay the Hawaiians, the Hawaiians would have accepted his apology more and would have not become so restless for independence.
ReplyDeleteI feel that Clinton should have offered more than just an oral apology. Although he could not offer independence to Hawaii, he could have made fiscal reparations or maybe proposed some special benefits for the native citizens of Hawaii in order to express sincere regret.
ReplyDeleteI agree the apology was somewhat lacking the true means of accepting what was done. Yes Clinton took the blame for what had happened but it ended there. There needs to be more maybe some sort of pennace to make up for it
ReplyDeleteI am glad you all agree. I wonder if President Clinton refused to make reparations because he was scared that that would lead to the Hawaiians asking for independence. Either way, since that is not plausible, he should have offered something tangible to make up for the past.
ReplyDelete