Below is a public service announcement that was released around the 2008 presidential election. The work is filled with a multitude of celebrities, who all work to urge Americans to vote via witty dialogue. Thus, this is a perfect example of the logical fallacy, "false authority." According to the writing 140 course book, "This fallacy bases its appeal on an authority figure who lacks competence in the field under consideration." All of the stars in question are in the entertainment industry. They do not work in politics and there is very little evidence to prove that they, themselves, engage in what they are trying to encourage the viewers to do. Not to mention the fact that some of the stars are actually from other countries. Therefore, they legally cannot participate in this display of democracy. For example, Sascha Baron Cohen and Orlando Bloom are from England, while Ryan Reynolds is from Canada.
Consequently, this type of logic can be extremely effective, but also dangerous. Celebrities nowadays have a great power over the public. Therefore, if they say they do something or buy something or use something, then the public tends to believe what the celebrities say without questioning the accuracy. However, in this situation, the celebrities are actually using the power and prestige that they have for good. Sometimes they can be found doing this for charities as well. Otherwise, they can be found shamelessly plugging hair colors, food, and other products.
Here is the example:
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis is an effective ad because people seem to listen to celebrities who they admire. Although these movie stars have no authority in politics, their "false authority" from stardom allows them to command people to vote just because they said so.
ReplyDeleteThis ad seems to not only utilize false authority but bandwagon as well as the ad incorporates all types of people from all different backgrounds and ages in order to convince people to vote by making it seem like everyone is voting.
Like Brenda said, this ad actually uses both fallacies of false authority and bandwagon. Since celebrities clearly do not deal with government and politics on a day to day basis, and since the ad is using people from a variety of backgrounds to encourage an action, both fallacies are committed.
ReplyDelete