There are a variety of practices that John Stewart criticizes surrounding the media's discourse on politics. In this episode, he focuses on CNN as a source of political news and debates. One aspect he attacks is how the news station seems to ignore the importance of fact-checking. A multitude of congressmen and other "authority figures" make televised speeches involving statistical figures, which are blindly accepted as truth. However, as John Stewart points out, the politicians are oftentimes wrong about the evidence they are using to support their arguments. Not only is the number inaccurate, they rarely commit themselves to citing a specific number. For instance, one man said "between one hundred to two hundred billion." He is incredibly vague, thus, giving himself the chance for his statement to be correct.
Another practice John Stewart criticizes is the role of the moderator in debates. Firstly, the moderator typically cuts people off when they are in the middle of a point in order to allow the other person to have equal time. Therefore, this ultimately makes the whole debate pointless. Often times this happens when the moderator says "Let's leave it there." Typically, this helps the show end within the allotted time slot that has been provided by the television station. However, as Stewart points out, CNN is a twenty-four hour news service. Therefore, there is no reason that they do not have time to completely cover all issues. Consequently, the moderator should not be working towards ending the debate. Instead, he or she should be fostering the debate, so that it continues.
There a few ways that these concerns can be addressed in academic discourse. One way is to require all discourse to be checked at least two times before it is aired. That way, when a politician speaks, he will not be able to persuade the audience with examples that are not accurate. Another way is to have the moderator more educated on the subject. Then, he or she will be more aware of faulty arguments and be able to call attention to this. Furthermore, CNN should allow more time for both sides in a debate to fully flush out their arguments. That way the debate is actually beneficial. Instead now, the audience is forced to watch people be cut off and frustrated on the television screen.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Your first two paragraphs clearly point out what Stewart is making fun of. Regarding statistics and fact-checking, anyone can just ramble off huge approximations so the actual answer will fall between the numbers. This practice is very common in newscasts and the news needs to enforce more rules about fact-checking, like you said. As for the "let's leave it there" phrase, I didn't realize how much it was really used until watching this video. It seems as though the moderator uses it whenever a debate starts to get rolling, thereby preventing the meat of the argument from being discussed. Newscasters should really look at Stewart's performance seriously and change some of the ways they report the news.
ReplyDeleteYour analysis of Jon Stewart's purpose is very clear and well-stated. I think your proposal for discourse to be checked twice before airing is a good idea. Oftentimes, well-known news stations such as CNN get away with presenting faulty information but the general public takes their news coverage as fact when it is not always accurate. Therefore, it is important to fact-check and provide credible news to the public.
ReplyDeleteCameron, like you said, I didn't realize how much the statement "let's leave it there" was used until Stewart pointed them out.
I liked how you prosed that it should be checked twice before it being said on air becuase it causes people to fully check the validity of information given. This would be helpful because people rely on CNN and other news sources to prived valid information and expect them to always give true things when in reality they dont dont always do that.
ReplyDelete