11.03.2009

Our Green Future: America's Young Environmental Leaders Speak Out

On Tuesday, October 27th, the second event in the speaker series for social issues occurred. There were three guests who were all Brower Youth Awardees with very impressive resumes. One was Rachel Barge, the director and founder of Campus Inpower, the second was Billy Parish, the founder of the Energy Action Coalition, and the third was Erica Fernandez, a student who has helped save her community from more toxic air pollution. There were many aspects of these presentations that made it more successful than the first talk, given by Simran Sethi. Firstly, this group was actually inspiring. They lead by example, showing that hard work can actually propel initiatives to become large, well-supported programs that make a difference in the world. All encouraged the audience that they had the power to do the same. Secondly, they were very organized in the points that they wanted to make. For instance, Billy Parish had a power point to accompany his speech, which broke down the facts he wanted to hit and thus, made a stronger impression on the audience. Thirdly, they all stressed the incredible importance of halting global warming and used facts and examples to substantiate their claims.

However, there were some negative aspects of their speeches. Firstly, like Sethi, they did not offer many solutions for how to stop global warming. Instead, they focused on explaining their efforts to stop global warming, rather than how the audience could join in the fight. This is a problem, because if the audience leaves inspired, but does not know what to do, then nothing will most likely come of it. Secondly, there were certain tactics that proved to be ineffective. For instance, the third speaker focused on race relations. Although, this is clearly a problem in terms of the environment and polluted areas, this should not have been the center of the speech. That is because it presents the audience with too many problems at once, and it is a proven fact that people who feel overwhelmed by issues in the world that need fixing, will typically not do anything. However, if people can channel all their energy to attack one problem, then tasks are accomplished. Therefore, it is for this reason that the speakers left a lasting impression, but had some logistics that needed to be fix.


If anyone is interested in learning more about the Brower Youth Awards or what we can do to help save the environment, check out the below link:

http://www.broweryouthawards.org/

4 comments:

  1. You made a very good assessment of the positive and negative aspects of the presentations. I didn't really notice any of the negative things about them until you pointed them out, which was probably because the presentations seemed great compared to Sethi's. I like your point about how although we may be left inspired, we still don't have any simple solutions to the problems. We were only given impressive stories about unique experiences, which are not all that common or easy to do to the average college student. In addition, I completely agree that the last speaker focused way too much on racial issues, as it was not the main issue at hand. She definitely shouldn't have talked about race to the extent that she did.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Even though Erica Fernandez shifted her focus slightly to race relations rather than just discussing the environment, I feel that her references to the injustice that certain races experience actually empowered her message more. She was able to emphasize that all people, regardless of ethnic background, should have access to clean air and unpolluted environments. However, in reality, this is not the case, so people definitely need to take notice of this inequality and strive to bring better environments to these deprived groups as well as the mainstream population.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with Brenda, by Erica disscussing the the treatment of races in society it does show that all people are capable of creating change. I do agree with you with the fact that if no solutions are presented than students will not know what to do in order to help the environment.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree that it was important for Erica Fernandez to discuss the issue of race. It made her overall argument better, simply because she points out that not only was it an environmental injustice, it was also a racial injustice as well. However, she needed to organize her speech better to convey that the main issue at hand was the environment and instead, the race issue was complementary.

    ReplyDelete