10.13.2009

Hawaiian Apology

As mentioned in the previous post, an apology was actually made by President Bill Clinton to the Hawaiians on behalf of the United States for overthrowing their government. Therefore, it is successful in that Clinton and Congress both acknowledge the crimes the government committed and seem genuinely sorry in doing so. However, it fails to offer a sound explanation as to why this happened, not to mention reparations. Thus, this makes the apology almost irrelevant, because by simply saying, "Yes, we did that," it does not actively take the first step towards the healing process. This, in turn, has made Native Hawaiians more restless for independence. Hence, in this case, the apology did more harm then good. This is because the American government publicly recognized its faults, but still is not going to make an effort to reverse the negative policies.

10.09.2009

Hawaiian Annexation

Around 1778, Hawaii was discovered by explorer James Cook, a man famous for his quests in the Pacific Ocean. After publications about various aspects of Hawaii, an increased amount of outsiders started flocking to the islands. Much like the Native Americans, the Hawaiians got brutally sick from exposure to certain diseases. Within the next seventy-five years or so, one-fifth of the entire population had perished. Eventually, Europeans and Americans started to grow in power in spite of the various monarchs. The 1887 Constitution of the Kingdom of Hawaii was the first step in the process. This bill largely took power away from the monarch by instituting a constitutional monarchy with a cabinet and legislature. In 1893, the Queen was replaced with a Provisional Government. At first, President Cleavland found this illegal, but a second investigation found parties involved not guilty and nothing was done in terms of reinstating the fallen monarch. Then, when McKinley became president, he annexed Hawaii as a territory and finally, in 1959, Hawaii was recognized as a state.

Later, President Bill Clinton made a formal apology claiming that the Hawaiian government was overthrown and the United States was responsible for it. This was known as the "Apology Resolution" and it was passed by Congress. However, many Hawaiians are not happy with this, because they want independence from the United States, an option they feel has never been presented to them. Thus, the apology, although nice, did not get anything accomplished in terms of establishing their own sovereignty, which they feel the United States did not have the right to take in the first place.

Below is a video that touches on the main points in the first installment. However, if you are interested it is one one of fifteen videos, which you can find on 1worldcitizen's youtube page.

10.05.2009

"Can We Save the Planet?" I'm still not sure...

On Tuesday, September 29th, Simran Sethi came to speak to an auditorium of college students. She spoke of the power to change existing within each of us, however, fell short of being inspiring. She thought that by leaving out facts and important information, she would somehow find a way to make this global issue more personal for us. Unfortunately, it had the opposite effect. As someone who has very general knowledge of the subject at hand, I felt isolated because I did not know much about the subject, which she took for granted that I did. What I think she may have overlooked is that tangible information resonates with students. For instance, we spend a lot of time reviewing documents and lectures that are filled with facts. Then we filter this and hold with us the ones that resonate. For instance, Professor Simpson telling us that there are languages dying every week makes me want to fix this problem, more so than him finding ways to point out how I connect with my own language. Therefore, the same logic can be applied to this worldwide crisis.

I also left the lecture feeling frustrated. For over an hour, she pointed out all the problems that were wrong with the environment. Yet, she never offered a solution to them. She mentioned using special light bulbs, but did so in a way that seemed like she was almost dismissing it. I understand that she was attempting to connect to us on a deeper level. However, she fell short of accomplishing this, by making her presentation disjointed, confusing, and lacking a clear point. Often times, she would mention an idea, which would seem like it could be the main one. Although, she never would reference back to it, thus, rendering it irrelevant. Therefore, overall, the discussion was uninformative.

9.29.2009

A Dying Language

One language that has been identified as endangered is 'Kallawaya.' This originated in Bolivia and currently, has less than one hundred speakers. Of the living speakers, most of them are older, hard of hearing, and sometimes aloof to the present situation. Thus, documenting the language for preservation purposes is almost impossible. Furthermore, in the documentary, "The Linguists," there was a man who thought he knew how to converse in this variety, but he actually had no idea. Thus, complications as listed compound the overall issue.

However, the main reason that this language has lost its status as being "safe," is because Spain colonized Bolivia. During that time, the majority language was imposed on the people. As Spanish took hold, Kallawaya stopped being passed down through the generations. Consequently, the language began dying out. If the language disappears, then their ancient medicinal practices will be lost, including a special cultural identity and world view. However, the hope exists that the language will essentially safeguard itself, because it coincides with the livelihood of the ritualistic healers.

The attached video is a bit more information about the Kallawaya on youtube. If you're at all interested in this, the clip gives more details about the healers specifically.

9.22.2009

Which Languages Are Worth Saving

Language extinction is clearly a burgeoning problem in the world. According to the "Linguists," languages are literally dying off every week. Unfortunately, it seems almost impossible to preserve every single one in existence. Thus, it is necessary to have qualifications for which languages are chosen to save. For it to be rescued, I think a written form must exist. This is because time typically is an antagonist to linguists. Therefore, if a written form has not yet been established, they will have to donate a large amount of effort to creating this. Consequently, they will waste precious time they have in discovering new words, phrases, and other nuances of the language in question. Another condition that should exist is the potential to be modernized. Like Evolution, if a language cannot adapt to the times, it cannot be used in all settings, especially for educational purposes.

On the other hand, a language that would not be worth saving is one that is spoken in a dangerous area. For instance, in "The Linguists," the men risk their lives by going to the Sora village, which harbors insurgents. Although it is noble to put protecting history before one's life, it should not be the norm. For example, had the men been killed, not only would the records they made of the language be lost, but so would they. Thus, there is no resulting benefit. Another condition that would make a language not worth saving would be if there are less than fifty speakers and it is not being passed down to generations. This is because there is an obvious lack of enthusiasm, which is crucial in this process.

Overall, it is hard to tell a group of people that their language is not "worth" saving. However, I truly believe that as long as there is a will, there is a way.

9.08.2009

Linguistics 115 and Critical Thinking

The Linguistics 115 class helps students develop critical thinking skills in a variety of ways. Firstly, it is required that essays are written in the class. Two of these, for example, forces the students to analyze films that are viewed and then to form a coherent opinion and conclusion about them. This, in turn, forces the students to think for themselves, instead of relying purely on the words of the professor. Furthermore, this incorporates an accommodation of uncertainty, because in terms of rhetoric, there is not a clear right or wrong answer. Secondly, the students have to attend discussion. During this time, students must decide what the intent is of certain articles, why particular facts are relevant, and why this information is important in today's world. In addition, this also incorporates an accommodation of uncertainty, because these thoughts are typically subjective and vary from person to person. Thus, the class as a whole helps foster critical thinking skills, by making students formulate ideas themselves via application of knowledge.

9.01.2009

"A German Lesson" Reviewed

During the article, "A German Lesson: the Fallacy of One True Path," by Daniel Jonah Goldhagen, the author makes an analogy between the Pope's beliefs and Nazi Germany's beliefs. He does this to suggest a similarity between the two. Like the Nazi's, the Pope feels that people of his kind are superior to any other. For example, the Pope believes in "relativism." Thus, he thinks the only way to get to Heaven is by being a Catholic. On the other hand, the Pope does not try to enslave and kill everyone else in his quest to form a super-race. Yet, Goldhagen suggests, simply through critical reasoning, that these exclusive theories evolve somewhat from Benedict's experience with the Nazis when he was younger. Furthermore, the author does it in a way that it is not precocious and accusatory. Rather, he uses rhetoric to make the reader come to the intended conclusion for himself or herself.